
What American, if our country were bombed and invaded, our families shot, burned, maimed, and raped, our environment destroyed and our wealth stolen, would not feel the same anger Iraqis feel? Americans in particular, so geographically and culturally isolated from most of the world, seem to have an inability to face our common humanity with others who look,
seem, so different from ourselves. It is a fearful effect, and Iraqi anger falls on deaf ears here.
"Even if you are an American with a weak stomach, it would be cowardly to avoid looking at what you voted for. If you can't bear to look, skip the pictures and read the text, and remember that if you cannot bear to even look at the suffering, how dare you insist anyone else bear the reality of it." -
Mindprod.comThe argument that the act of talking about the reality of war, of showing pictures of the violence of war, or of speaking out against war, hurts our soldiers is... well, panicky. It is irrational. Soldiers in combat see war every day, they need no education on pain and violence. They are already experts, whether they like it or not. And those soldiers will bring their pain home with them. So why is it that those who argue this would not allow
non-soldiers to see it? Why create this buffer of ignorance? Why pretend that what is happening is not? The American public shrinks from confronting the truth about war, and we allow our government; allow the television, to lie to us every day and every night, year after year. In Iraq human bodies are burned, shot, blown to pieces, while at home we play pretend-soldier in fancy Hummers, ribbon magnets on display, and
make up mythologies about ourselves.
Why do we do this?
The other day I heard an
interview on NPR with a certain Gunnery Sargeant Jack Coughlin, Marine sniper, and apparently one of their "best" snipers. He is obviously an intelligent man, and was able to finely articulate his own internal justifications for having killed so many other human beings. He mentioned the particular strain of being able to see his target's face before pulling the trigger, and the later emotional impact upon himself as a result. He was clearly a mature man, and has children at home that he is now caring for lovingly as a single dad. He obviously has thought a great deal about his role as a sniper. But even after his explanations, I believe he was not being fully honest. His interviewer was careful not to step on toes by asking any provocative questions, and he was careful to say that he reserves a certain gallantry in his shielding us, and his fellow soldiers, from the wrench of seeing up close the destruction of the bodies and faces he hit. And then he said this: "Nobody has more respect for human life than I do."
Really? Nobody?
He meant for us to know how much he values life, in effect he was saying "I am not
that kind of killer," and "I was protecting the other soldiers," and, "I feel this deeply and it has hurt me, but I will bear it for all of our sakes." But to say this is to assume we owe him a debt for making his choices. It is an illusion that he has that kind of power, and the truth is that neither he nor any other soldier can really protect any of us. We all must finally admit powerlessness, it is ultimately unavoidable. Our fates, and our children's fates, always lie with God and nowhere else. And he and the radio interviewer pretended there were no other questions that might be asked.
God has given us the capacity to decide - the free will to choose our course. I cannot accept the obligation this nobility Coughlin clearly feels demands, and I believe it is wrong for us to imagine we owe him something for having killed on the battlefield. Aggression is never necessary, it is only desired. War is never demanded by God. We did not have to be there in that desert. Jack Coughlin did not have to be there in that desert, and no death associated with this war had to happen.
I have never blamed our young men and women in combat for the obscene governmental policies that put them in Iraq (or any other war), and have been more than willing to understand the nature of the terrible instability and insecurity they daily experience. They are faced with a veritable Hell on Earth, a man-made monstrosity of failure, and once there, must somehow survive to come home. But I find it far easier to understand the 19-year-old on hair-trigger adrenaline alert mistakenly opening fire at a roadside checkpoint than I do this mature Gunnery Sargeant. At least the jittery young soldier thinks he is protecting himself. The thing is, Coughlin clearly knows his acts of killing were morally wrong, and not only that, he knows just
how wrong it was. He knows what pain it caused, to himself and to others. He knows how it feels to love his children, and yet has made himself able to kill others' families. To know this and do it anyway, is merely obedience. It would have taken far more courage to walk away from it. His attempts to explain merely illustrates his own understanding of the moral distortion it took to perform his job. He made his justifications in order to allow himself to continue. As he describes the "necessity" of conciously choosing to dehumanize another person in order to kill them, he admits he must lie to himself about these human beings in order to take the shot. But why?
Really, I want to understand why. What for? What is it that a soldier gets out of it? What payoff does battle bring? People do not do difficult things for no reason. And killing is a difficult thing, as the military knows so well - it is the reason for their indoctrination of recruits - a soldier must undergo a separation of their free will, a divorce from their human nature, in order to allow themselves to be trained to kill. There is always a payoff of some sort, no matter how bad the deal may turn out to be in the end. There is a reason soldiers do this, choose this profession, choose to pull the trigger. But what is that reason? What benefit do they get? What benefit did Jack Coughlin get out of going to war?
Leaving aside the many, many enlisted soldiers who are there for the college money only and never thought they would end up in Iraq, there are also many, many enlisted soldiers who are there because they wanted to be. They wanted to fly to another country, engage it's people, bomb them, shoot them, and take over their land. They
wanted to be a part of that, and said so, some quite gleefully. Many were not so gleeful, but wanted to go just as intensely. And this cannot be completely explained by having ingested so much propaganda from the Bush administration, although those lies sunk in deeply, no doubt.
I do not feel I owe any soldier my gratitude. I do not thank them for killing any more than I thank our government for killing. I do believe I owe the soldiers respect, but I also believe we
all owe each other respect. I respect them, but no more than I respect the teen-age single mother raising children in poverty. No more than I respect the farmer, the firefighter, the schoolteacher. No more than I respect the dignity of the citizens of
all countries. No more than I respect myself. I believe speaking the truth about war
is showing respect for the soldiers. They deserve for us all to know the facts of what they have been through.
But I am not grateful for the deaths, or for their willingness to kill. God grants me my freedom, not soldiers, not politicians, not governments, not false power. God gives us these gifts, and we are the ones who choose war, death and destruction - we are the ones who use God as a justification for inflicting pain upon others.
I understand the pride of marksmanship, of true mastery of a skill, even if that skill is keeping a steady hand and detaching oneself from one's own moral integrity in order to "perform." It is difficult, quite an accomplishment even, this division of an intelligent self, this absolute, pathological self-control, this action in spite of one's own moral awareness. But I think there are other compelling emotional factors at work. War is about power, and because of that, it means that at the heart of it, it's about fear. Fear of the loss of power. Fear of worthlessness. Fear of ridicule. Fear of being insignificant. Fear of insecurity. The plain and simple truth is, and has been for all of human history, that young soldiers go eagerly off to war because they see no better (or perhaps easier) way to gain recognition, to gain a little bit of societal power. To make their mark on the world. To hold a bit of influence in their hands (and what
seems more immediately influential than a firearm?)
What does this say about us as a people, that our children do not already see God's love and creation in themselves, just as they are? That it becomes possible for them to see the death of others as a valid path to acceptance, glory, and righteousness?
I find myself asking why we Americans have developed such a blind spot. Why have we seemed to have dissociated ourselves as citizens, as human beings even, from our own self-professed religious beliefs? From our own founding ideals? We
say we believe in things like "love", "Jesus", and "moral values." We
say we believe in "Democracy." But as a society, we virtually ignore the very real, hateful, violent consequences of our actions. As "news" shows like the one on NPR drone on, we citizens have given ourselves a pass.
This is why soldiers will scream at someone like me, or even at their
fellow soldiers, for pointing out the truths of what happens in war. This is why soldiers, if they live through war, will pretend that the "honor" they received was worth all the death, dismemberment, and destruction. It is because it is too hard to bear: they were duped into thinking that to kill another human being was an honorable duty, a worthy endeavor. Perhaps they were too practiced in self-deception to begin with. Or, perhaps they were too young to know, and now must bear the weight of their own selves for the rest of their lives, while the community around them remains willfully ignorant of the truth, polite niceties serving as a poor substitute for understanding.
Deep down inside they have traded something of the best part of themselves, something far greater for that scrap of recognition. They have traded their own peace of mind, their own sense of humanity. They have traded the love they were born with, traded it for an empty medal. Some combat veterans manage to get it back, but it is a long hard road, and it is no small wonder that many do not make it, or end up alcoholic and full of rage. It is no small wonder the veteran suicide rate is so high.
There are many people who scream (and they always scream) "the soldiers are preserving YOUR freedom!" and "you should shut up!" but to me this simply shows the everyday face of fear. When people say such things, all I hear is "Please please don't say these things out loud. Please don't rock the boat." They forget that war doesn't just affect the soldier; violence created in the world begets more violence in the world for all of us. His pain is spread in the theatre of the battlefield, then brought home with him, and we must all pay the cost of his losses. What might he have become otherwise? Who might he have been? And will he be able to fight himself back to peace of mind, to loving acceptance of himself ?
Aggression, war, firearms, bombs; these are not real power. These things are simply tools used by the fearful, by those who have lost their faith in the love of God. Because no matter what a soldier has done, no matter what crimes were committed, no matter what mistakes were made, no matter how many innocents died, there is forgiveness in God. And because no matter what lies a politician tells, no matter who gets to deposit great amounts of money, in the end they are only human and they are subject to the same Creator as the rest of us. And no matter how blind we allow ourselves to be, no matter how hard we strive for security, we will none of us escape death, pain, and suffering. There exists no guarantee, and as human beings we can never really Know. There may never be forgiveness from other human beings, but in faith, God always, always, always brings us back. Even those of us who voted for something
we refuse to look at. In the end the
only thing we have to call our own is faith. And the only real power is in that faith. All else is an illusion. Winning is an illusion. And so is defeat.
"Hell is yourself and the only redemption is when a person puts himself aside to feel deeply for another person." --Tennessee Williams